You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
You most certainly should not FAQ a game 'off the manual alone'. Just because games back then had to have all of their mechanics written in a manual does not mean that all manuals were actually sufficient sources of gameplay information. Take a look at the board for Batman Forever. There is a topic there detailing an entire move list that was never included in the manual, something a player would have no clue about if they read a guide solely sourced from the manual and not actual playtime.
Also, platformers. Most of the platformer games I have done have had tricky segments that were counterintuitive, or just required lots of aimless wandering to figure out what to do next.
^Just another observation. I wouldn't be so quick to cross-link every FAQ you're doing, unless you've been doing research on the different versions and can conclude they are all the same game. This is why we were very cautious about doing this for the NES project.
Devin Morgan | CRP #3579 NES FAQ Completion Project: http://faqs.retronintendo.com
GameFAQs bolding is not accurate, from my own experience.
My first guide (Looney Tunes: Back in Action) kept getting linked with the GBA version and I kept having to tell this site to remove the inaccurate cross-link. Each time I uploaded the guide when this Bold system appeared, it kept [or seemed to] automatically link my guide to the GBA version, even though I made sure it was unticked and the GC version was checked [both were cross-linked] [this appears to be fixed, based on the last time I uploaded a revision of this guide]. As I owned both the PS2 and GBA versions of the game, I knew they were completely different games and no crosslink should occur. Also, I have mentioned it in the comments that the GBA version should not be bold as it is nothing like the PS2 version, but it is still bold last time I checked [which was while writing this post].
I have also had issues with other GameFAQs bolding games, but could not provide details as I generally did not get the hate email that occured with the above example.
Track FAQs - http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/7-site-suggestions/53099536 System Requirements - http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/7-site-suggestions/53203289
Uploaded FAQs for Disney's Hercules and Mouse Trap Hotel.
@ Glacoras - I think it was mentioned in the FAQer changes topic how to fix your issue, if you're curious. @ RiP - If you've got time, can you check the CP site to see what claims I have remaining? I know there's Godzilla (in progress), Skate Or Die: Tour de Thrash (haven't received), and Dennis the Menace (not received), but I can't pull up the site to check for some reason. Probably this slow internet. :P
Total Files / Complete FAQs / Images / KB -- 165 / 126 / 4 / ~24,634 KB. Proud Leader of Team Ancient Legends (PMD2). Total Rescues: 1,766.