Save/Load Anywhere VS Restart From Checkpoint

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. BioShock Infinite
  3. Save/Load Anywhere VS Restart From Checkpoint

User Info: Goldsickle

Goldsickle
3 years ago#1
Which Save/Load Format Do You Prefer? - Results (81 votes)
Save/Load almost anywhere in the game (Bioshock and Bioshock 2)
90.12% (73 votes)
73
Can only restart from a previous checkpoint, game autosaves when reaching the next checkpoint (Bioshock Infinite)
9.88% (8 votes)
8
This poll is now closed.
Do you like the new save/load format in Bioshock Infinite?

At least there seems to be a chapter select, so I guess that means you can specifically look for missed items without the need to replay a new game?
There is no such thing as a "Quick Time Event done right".
A game that has Quick Time Events is a "video game done wrong".

User Info: JayGood259Oz

JayGood259Oz
3 years ago#2
This game is prefer manual saves, however tomb raider had the best autosaves I ever saw, never had to back track more than 1 minute. Regardless of save method having only 1 save slot is totally unacceptable ... Again, tomb raider let you have 3 even though they were all autosaves.

twice in infinite I had to back track a half hour because I hadn't reached an autosave and I wanted to quit. One time I literally lost 2 voxophones, a clothing item, a cipher book and a potion.

User Info: Jdarrz

Jdarrz
3 years ago#3
Not to be mean but.... this question is pretty obvious and unnecessary. This is like asking do you want to pick any food for dinner or do you want a choice of 5 items you can choose to eat for dinner.

No matter the circumstance or situation or subject.... why would any one EVER not want infinite (no pun intended) choices, and prefer to have only a few options. Do you really think anyone is going to be like oh yeah take away all options from me and only save when the game wants, instead of letting us save any time any place?....

Another random metaphor.... this question is like asking: would you prefer to choose ANY car you want? or which car would you choose from a choice of a Civic, Miata, or Mustang?
I hope you get my point by now....

>_<

User Info: Goldsickle

Goldsickle
3 years ago#4
Jdarrz posted...
Not to be mean but.... this question is pretty obvious and unnecessary. This is like asking do you want to pick any food for dinner or do you want a choice of 5 items you can choose to eat for dinner.

No matter the circumstance or situation or subject.... why would any one EVER not want infinite (no pun intended) choices, and prefer to have only a few options. Do you really think anyone is going to be like oh yeah take away all options from me and only save when the game wants, instead of letting us save any time any place?....

Another random metaphor.... this question is like asking: would you prefer to choose ANY car you want? or which car would you choose from a choice of a Civic, Miata, or Mustang?
I hope you get my point by now....

>_<

I totally understand your point and always look at objective pros and cons.

But no matter how much you try to explain, there are still those who like things to be less flexible for whatever reason.
There is no such thing as a "Quick Time Event done right".
A game that has Quick Time Events is a "video game done wrong".

User Info: JayGood259Oz

JayGood259Oz
3 years ago#5
Goldsickle posted...
Jdarrz posted...
Not to be mean but.... this question is pretty obvious and unnecessary. This is like asking do you want to pick any food for dinner or do you want a choice of 5 items you can choose to eat for dinner.

No matter the circumstance or situation or subject.... why would any one EVER not want infinite (no pun intended) choices, and prefer to have only a few options. Do you really think anyone is going to be like oh yeah take away all options from me and only save when the game wants, instead of letting us save any time any place?....

Another random metaphor.... this question is like asking: would you prefer to choose ANY car you want? or which car would you choose from a choice of a Civic, Miata, or Mustang?
I hope you get my point by now....

>_<

I totally understand your point and always look at objective pros and cons.

But no matter how much you try to explain, there are still those who like things to be less flexible for whatever reason.


Like I said above, I love the idea of a good autosave like in tomb raider. This one isn't good though. I do don't think you need the option to save any time here, just needed more autosaves locations.

a game like fallout, or any open world game u need manual saves.

User Info: MikeSSJ part 3

MikeSSJ part 3
3 years ago#6
I like checkpoints and autosaves.


In addition to the ability to save anytime, that is. That way, I can quit at any time, or keep a save at a point I really like, and still not run the risk of losing much progress because I haven't saved in a while.
You know, Moffat made such a big deal out of the Silence, and yet I don't even remember what they look like...

User Info: AdrianMagicent

AdrianMagicent
3 years ago#7
1999 and survival mode... I definitely wish you could save at will. Some of the checkpoints are definitely designed for the lesser modes, it seemed to me. This game is also very annoying with all those saves!!
Dubito, ergo sim.

User Info: Goldsickle

Goldsickle
3 years ago#8
Whenever I play games like Deus Ex or Bioshock, I always save first before pulling some weird s***.

At some point, I was told that "Stealing May Have Severe Consequences".

If only this game has a "save anywhere" format, I would have saved first and steal from the cash register just to see what happens.
But because this game lacks that format, I was too chicken to try D:
There is no such thing as a "Quick Time Event done right".
A game that has Quick Time Events is a "video game done wrong".

User Info: Doubleglock18

Doubleglock18
3 years ago#9
why not both? sure have your checkpoints and autosaves, but also have the ability to save anywhere. easy.
Colt 45 and two zig-zags, Baby that's all we need
We can go to the park, after dark, smoke that tumbleweed!

User Info: Dave_is_my_name

Dave_is_my_name
3 years ago#10
The save system was the only real let down of the game IMO.
  1. Boards
  2. BioShock Infinite
  3. Save/Load Anywhere VS Restart From Checkpoint

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived