You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
Gamespot and metacritic for the most part, but even then I depend on what I see from trailers and user reviews to buy games or if it's from a franchise I like. I also buy on just pure gut sometimes if that makes any sense.
The main reason why I don't let reviews sway my decision is because of Dynasty Warriors. I love those games to death and they usually average 5/10's.
since there are so many, I'll just say my most trusted is Gameinformer. About 90% of the time, their views fall in line with my own.
The one I don't trust at all is Gamespot, for a number of reasons. The quality of that site in general just keeps falling imo. It used to be G4 for me, but since they're pretty much gone anyways, Gamespot is the site I never trust.
I like Gametrailers reviews the most. They usually acknowledge everything good and everything bad about a game. Which is good, since it allows me to identify which issues might bother me to a greater extent or what features might be underwhelming to me as well.
I also like Joystiq's, IGN's, Kotaku's, and a few other lesser known.