Should Shiny Pokemon have better stats than normal PKMN?

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. Pokemon Black Version 2
  3. Should Shiny Pokemon have better stats than normal PKMN?

User Info: MetaXGross

MetaXGross
4 years ago#1
Should Shiny Pokemon have better stats than normal PKMN? - Results (174 votes)
Yes.
20.69% (36 votes)
36
No.
59.77% (104 votes)
104
Maybe.
8.05% (14 votes)
14
I don't care.
11.49% (20 votes)
20
This poll is now closed.
Topic.
Not changing until the Lions win the Superbowl. 7-17-07

User Info: AmephEstMako

AmephEstMako
4 years ago#2
No
He died of cancer...which caused bullet wounds to appear on his body.
PFC: 0131 4016 5507

User Info: CrystalKing5426

CrystalKing5426
4 years ago#3
It's just a palette swap that's really rare. Giving them BST boosts would wreck the metagame.

User Info: CrystalKing5426

CrystalKing5426
4 years ago#4
Hey, while we're at it, let's give stat changes to alternate costumes in fighting games.

User Info: MetaXGross

MetaXGross
4 years ago#5
CrystalKing5426 posted...
It's just a palette swap that's really rare. Giving them BST boosts would wreck the metagame.


Not boosts like that, but boosts as in they had better IV's, maybe EV's too, or something like that. I don't play Competitive, but I think it makes a little bit of sense to make the Shinies somewhat better. It could be abused, like restarting for a Shiny Starter, or any free Pokemon that you get. I don't really mind that though, a lot may.

Also, it makes up for how ugly some of them are. =]
Not changing until the Lions win the Superbowl. 7-17-07

User Info: kuwab0

kuwab0
4 years ago#6
CrystalKing5426 posted...
It's just a palette swap that's really rare. Giving them BST boosts would wreck the metagame.


Good.

User Info: Ku-Ri-Boh

Ku-Ri-Boh
4 years ago#7
You'll get more complaints. Spending 1 more hour to breed a good Pokemon for competitive battle already is hated beyond belief, and now you want the metagame to be filled with nothing but shinies?

I'd be okay if Shiny has other less important but cool gimmicks like better for contests, better for Pokethlon, etc, but NEVER INVOLVE IT WITH THE COMPETITIVE SCENE

User Info: MetaXGross

MetaXGross
4 years ago#8
CrystalKing5426 posted...
Hey, while we're at it, let's give stat changes to alternate costumes in fighting games.


I don't compare it to a different costumes. I compare it a bit to the show. Wasn't Ash's Noctowl Shiny, and a bit stronger?

I compare it that since it's rare to have a Shiny Pokemon that it could be a gene mutation of some sort that causes them to be Shiny. A bonus would be better programmed stats.
Not changing until the Lions win the Superbowl. 7-17-07

User Info: coreekymon

coreekymon
4 years ago#9
I wouldn't mind if they automatically had like a minimum of 15 for each IV just so you couldn't get one that was disgusting in the IV department. Anything beyond that I wouldn't want.
Please check out my blog/guide to competitive pokemon at pkmntrainercory.blogspot.com

User Info: MetaXGross

MetaXGross
4 years ago#10
Ku-Ri-Boh posted...
You'll get more complaints. Spending 1 more hour to breed a good Pokemon for competitive battle already is hated beyond belief, and now you want the metagame to be filled with nothing but shinies?

I'd be okay if Shiny has other less important but cool gimmicks like better for contests, better for Pokethlon, etc, but NEVER INVOLVE IT WITH THE COMPETITIVE SCENE


Sorry wow, I didn't think you guys were so passionate about that stuff...Since I don't play Competitive, I see it as a easy way to beat the in-game, even if it is easy enough as it is. Or battling my friends who don't Competitiveplay either, just play in-game. Or to just give them a reason to want them other then them just being a different color and sparkles.

But that's why I said it would be abused. And who knows, What if it had a bad Nature, would that still ruin it or no? I'm not saying the increase has to be anything high, maybe just +1-5 in each IV & EV stat. 1-3 might be better.
Not changing until the Lions win the Superbowl. 7-17-07
  1. Boards
  2. Pokemon Black Version 2
  3. Should Shiny Pokemon have better stats than normal PKMN?

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived
More topics from this board...
EVs explained! PLEASE READ!jayman71286/7 11:42AM