This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Why such a discrepancy between user reviews and media reviews for "Gone Home"?

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. PC
  3. Why such a discrepancy between user reviews and media reviews for "Gone Home"?

User Info: shooterfan22

shooterfan22
3 years ago#1
topic

User Info: Lemur_H

Lemur_H
3 years ago#2
Price and attention span.

User Info: PhilOnDez

PhilOnDez
3 years ago#3
This might come off as bad on my part but a reviewer has their name on the line and saying the game isn't very good will more than likely result in accusations of homophobia which could very easily lead to a blacklisting. The average consumer isn't worried about that though so they can just say what they feel and not worry about it.

I haven't actually played it so I can't comment on its quality, it sounds like it should have been $10 tops though, I think if it had just been cheaper there wouldn't have been nearly as many negative reviews.
Every time I try to go where I really wanna be it's already where I am, 'cuz I'm already there
XBL, PSN, Steam, Origin, BSN, GFAQs, MC: PhilOnDez

User Info: Slayn

Slayn
3 years ago#4
How anyone could give a 90m game where you walk around in a house doing nothing a good review... I don't know.
#1 LoL Poster NA: http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/954437-league-of-legends/63627116

User Info: Featherwind

Featherwind
3 years ago#5
In the other thread there were concerns of it exploiting the current attitudes towards the LGBT thing.

Also...

AdamantRock posted...
Two words: Oscar bait. The subject matter was all most reviewers needed to award it a perfect score. Never mind how short it is or how non-interactive. Some people bash Naughty Dog games and Heavy Rain as barely interactive movies, but that appellation has never been so applicable as with this thing.


I don't know what exactly is Oscar bait but the explanation on TvTropes could indeed fit this game to some extent.

Many players felt like the story was there to further some outside agenda. I haven't played it so I can't really judge however.

User Info: ShadowThaReaper

ShadowThaReaper
3 years ago#6
It's a 2 hour story with literally no gameplay. And it panders to the LGBT crowd.

Every critic feels like they have to praise it, because it makes them look intellectual.

User Info: shooterfan22

shooterfan22
3 years ago#7
Just played it. It's pretty good... but not a 9/10.

User Info: Sk0rbut

Sk0rbut
3 years ago#8
Critics play a lot more games than the average consumer so they are more inclined to like stuff that differs from everything else. Also: pandering to the LGBT community? What is this, the Fox News board?
I am the bringer of death. Fall to your knees and beg for mercy... Or give me a sandwich, I'm pretty hungry.

User Info: shooterfan22

shooterfan22
3 years ago#9
Sk0rbut posted...
Critics play a lot more games than the average consumer so they are more inclined to like stuff that differs from everything else. Also: pandering to the LGBT community? What is this, the Fox News board?


Tell me about it.

How about pandering to people in favor of progressive equality and acceptance.

User Info: AlleRacing

AlleRacing
3 years ago#10
Reviewing something highly just for a group to feel accepted is pretty invalid. The sentiment may be nice and thoughtful, but it should have no bearing on a professional review. The game should be reviewed on its merit, not the number of contemporary social issues it addresses.
http://img356.imageshack.us/img356/8325/scrunchface2copyfx0.png
http://www.xboxlc.com/cards/default/alle5.jpg
  1. Boards
  2. PC
  3. Why such a discrepancy between user reviews and media reviews for "Gone Home"?

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived