This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

JRPG's aren't really Role Playing Games

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. PC
  3. JRPG's aren't really Role Playing Games

User Info: HighOnPhazon

HighOnPhazon
2 years ago#31
Jprime666 posted...
And yet they're better than western role playing games.


Like I said, I like and in the past have enjoyed JRPG's but no, they are not better than WRPG's in the ROLE PLAYING aspect.
PC Gaming - The Only Way
i5 3570K / ASRock Z77 Extreme 4 / Patriot Viper 8GB /Sapphire Radeon HD 7970 3GB/ Corsair TX650

User Info: harcoreblazer

harcoreblazer
2 years ago#32
Any games that involve these gameplay mechanics should be considered RPGs.

-Leveling up your character
-Developing skills and stats
-Stats affect gameplay
-Characters that have an specific role in combat.

Also, why do the variations of RPG even exist? I can understand some of them (MMORPG, Action RPG, Dungeon Crawling RPG) but JRPG and WRPG don't make sense.

We should just call them RPGs and that's it :/.
PSN/Steam = retrohunter95.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QS4HQWWuqP8&feature=youtu.be

User Info: HighOnPhazon

HighOnPhazon
2 years ago#33
harcoreblazer posted...
Any games that involve these gameplay mechanics should be considered RPGs.

-Leveling up your character
-Developing skills and stats
-Stats affect gameplay
-Characters that have an specific role in combat.

Also, why do the variations of RPG even exist? I can understand some of them (MMORPG, Action RPG, Dungeon Crawling RPG) but JRPG and WRPG don't make sense.

We should just call them RPGs and that's it :/.


Well, that is actually a good point.
PC Gaming - The Only Way
i5 3570K / ASRock Z77 Extreme 4 / Patriot Viper 8GB /Sapphire Radeon HD 7970 3GB/ Corsair TX650

User Info: Askeladd

Askeladd
2 years ago#34
Well, traditionally there were certain elements associated with Japanese and Western RPGs, but as the genre expands and elements of east and western games start to homogenize, the terms JRPG and WRPG have become less relevant. I think that with time they will just die out.
TWSS hes speken end the wenner es E. There cen enle be ene.
"If it can fit in a Pokeball it can fit in a Gatorade bottle. I'mma catch it." NobleRoar

User Info: Ningishzida

Ningishzida
2 years ago#35
harcoreblazer posted...
Any games that involve these gameplay mechanics should be considered RPGs.

-Leveling up your character


You don't level up in Deus Ex or Vampire bloodlines, I guess they're not RPGs to you.

User Info: mogexpress1

mogexpress1
2 years ago#36
Ningishzida posted...
Nice trolling attempt, but like most trolling attempts, it's more style over substance.


actually I was just going for style

But yeah luck is a way bigger factor on this side of the pond and there is no denying that. It makes the few hard SRPGs over there more tactical than anything over here.
Daddy's home
Shut up gabe and take my money

User Info: xpiritflare

xpiritflare
2 years ago#37
harcoreblazer posted...
Also, why do the variations of RPG even exist? I can understand some of them (MMORPG, Action RPG, Dungeon Crawling RPG) but JRPG and WRPG don't make sense.

We should just call them RPGs and that's it :/.

We did, 10-15 years ago, back then it was just console rpg and computer rpg.
I don't recall the terms (J and W) being said nearly this much during the 6th gen of consoles. It was the 7th gen that popularized the terms.
Yeah. "I'm going to turn back time an hour. It'll take about an hour." - AnnaBananaa

User Info: ThePonyCollie

ThePonyCollie
2 years ago#38
As long as you have Attack, Defense, Damage, Magic, etc in your game, it's an RPG.
No Steam, no buy.

User Info: xanthan1

xanthan1
2 years ago#39
Ningishzida posted...
harcoreblazer posted...
Any games that involve these gameplay mechanics should be considered RPGs.

-Leveling up your character


You don't level up in Deus Ex or Vampire bloodlines, I guess they're not RPGs to you.


You level up your various stats and disciplines in Bloodlines. Did you somehow completely miss that? Just because it isn't every stat going up once doesn't mean it isn't leveling up.

But please, do go on about how earning exp and using it to improve your character by increasing it's stats or getting better abilities isn't leveling up.

harcoreblazer posted...

Also, why do the variations of RPG even exist? I can understand some of them (MMORPG, Action RPG, Dungeon Crawling RPG) but JRPG and WRPG don't make sense.

We should just call them RPGs and that's it :/.


Because grouping Final Fantasy and Baldurs Gate together with no distinction is kind of stupid. They're both RPGs, for a given and kind of broad definition of RPG, but they play nothing alike. I mean would you group Dragon Age and Mass Effect in the same genre as Dragon Quest and Final Fantasy with no distinction between them? Or what about any of those and Dungeons of Dredmor?

User Info: Ningishzida

Ningishzida
2 years ago#40
xanthan1 posted...
You level up your various stats and disciplines in Bloodlines. Did you somehow completely miss that? Just because it isn't every stat going up once doesn't mean it isn't leveling up.

But please, do go on about how earning exp and using it to improve your character by increasing it's stats or getting better abilities isn't leveling up.


There are no levels in Deus Ex or Bloodlines, therefore it isn't leveling up.

And if you had any degree of reading comprehension, and a memory more than one post long, you would have also seen that hardcoreblazer differentiated between "Leveling up your character" and "Developing skills and stats". But you don't in both cases, so that's why your unsuccessful attempt at correcting me comes off as doubly foolish. Don't try so hard next time, you might burst a blood vessel. Instead, just agree with me, because I've proved over and over again my RPG erudition and eloquence far exceeds your paltry dabblings and your posts are nothing but twaddle in the face of mine.
  1. Boards
  2. PC
  3. JRPG's aren't really Role Playing Games

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived