This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Civ IV Complete vs Civ V vanilla for a newcomer

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. PC
  3. Civ IV Complete vs Civ V vanilla for a newcomer

User Info: HaxnStash

3 years ago#1
Hello everyone. I've been interested in this type of game but whenever I start playing, it gets too complicated. I always get overwhelmed with what I have to do first, what to concentrate first and which research to do first.

I plan on trying it again and I was wondering which of the 2 will help me understand and learn.

So far, I've tried Sins of a Solar Empire and a very little bit of Civ V.

Thank you in advance.

User Info: Clashtonn

3 years ago#2
Civ 5 Complete >>>>>>>>> Civ 4 Complete >>> Civ 5 vanilla
i5 somethingK | GTX 660TI and some letters | Like 8 rams or something| Really Big HDD | Kind of small SDD

User Info: spud_almighty

3 years ago#3
Civ V is a much more enjoyable experience than Civ IV. It's alot more beginner friendly also.

User Info: anonymous46773

3 years ago#4
CIv 4 has a bigger focus on empire building and diplomacy while Civ 5 has a bigger focus on combat.

IIRC, Civ 4 actually has a pretty decent tutorial built in, but you should be able to get into either, especially since they have little suggestions on what to build next. Just do what they suggest for your first few games and you should do fine.
I asked God for a bike, but I know God doesn't work that way. So I stole a bike and asked for forgiveness.

User Info: Englandfc1966

3 years ago#5
Get this instead

User Info: Clashtonn

3 years ago#6
Englandfc1966 posted...
Get this instead

lol oh yeah, definitely newbie friendly right?
i5 somethingK | GTX 660TI and some letters | Like 8 rams or something| Really Big HDD | Kind of small SDD

User Info: arleas

3 years ago#7
I liked Civ IV "vanilla" better than Civ V with all the expansions. Civ V without expansions sucks ass and with expansions is much better (but still not quite up to par in my opinion).

Basically they took a bunch of stuff out of Civ IV to make Civ V, and then with the expansions started putting it back in.

The one thing Civ V did right (in the expansions) is they made religion mean more... in Civ IV religion is pretty neutered so as to not offend anyone by inadvertently making religion X more powerful than religion Y. In Civ V they added ways to modify your religion so that you can pretty much build it into the way you want it.

Civ IV also runs quite a bit better on older computers though I know Civ V has a mode where you can turn the graphics down to almost nothing.

Civ V also has city states which act as little cities that aren't competing for world domination, and basically just throw tantrums until you do what they want (or stomp them into the ground). At first I thought it was neat, but after playing a while I started hating the way they wanted you to constantly appease them so they'd stay on your good side.

tl;dr Civ V has a lot of advancements over Civ IV but took all the expansions to make it worth playing. Civ IV doesn't have these advancements but the plain game was more fun to me... no expansion necessary.

User Info: Sinfullyvannila

3 years ago#8
Civ 5 is easier to learn. Civ 4 is not difficult to learn though and has a great tutorial. It's just not quite as intuitive, and not as transparent as 5. I'd have to say 5 is better just because they really worked on the late game with the latest expansion.

Both great games. Definitely spring for Civ 5 complete when you see it on sale. If you're on the fence though, Civ 4 is much cheaper. I'd actually say it's kind of a waste of money to get just vanilla 5. Just because the expansions are such no brainers.
Yes, said game is worth $5. {3DS Friend Code 3050-7626-8586}

User Info: iammaxhailme

3 years ago#9
Clashtonn posted...
Civ 5 Complete >>>>>>>>> Civ 4 Complete >>> Civ 5 vanilla

Best weapon combo in tf2:

User Info: ElDudorino

3 years ago#10
I'd take Civ 4 vanilla over Civ 5 vanilla or Civ 5 with Gods & Kings. I don't know about the other expansions for it. Civ 5 has enough annoying little quirks in it that I'm not sure it's really easier to learn than Civ 4. And anyway, no Civ game (or Alpha Centauri) has ever been THAT hard to learn. There's a learning curve before you get good at each game, but just start on a lower difficulty and explore the tech trees and experiment in battles until you get the hang of things.
  1. Boards
  2. PC
  3. Civ IV Complete vs Civ V vanilla for a newcomer

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived