This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Tadhg Kelly: "Games can't tell stories"

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. PlayStation 3
  3. Tadhg Kelly: "Games can't tell stories"

User Info: Tubula

Tubula
6 years ago#1
http://www.next-gen.biz/opinion/opinion-games-cant-tell-stories

I've read some stupid troll-bait this year, but this just takes the cake. While yes, not every game tells a good story, her argument is that games cannot tell stories, period; which is just not the case.
What is a Mega Man? A miserable little pile of circuits! But enough talk, have at you!

User Info: apocalyptic_4

apocalyptic_4
6 years ago#2
this person hasnt played alot of games, thats what i got from reading that.
PSN: Adrian396 2nd Ac PSN:Apocalypse369 3rd AcApoc369
XBL: Adrian369Ford

User Info: zyrax2301

zyrax2301
6 years ago#3
No game can spin a yarn like a woman can.
Why? Because **** you is why.

User Info: B4LChamp

B4LChamp
6 years ago#4
lol, a dude wrote this article
I go to sleep, dream that I'm Finnegan, then wake up, Joycian

User Info: ArsenicOverlord

ArsenicOverlord
6 years ago#5
*sees a picture of a balding guy next to the article with the writer credit*

So where is this "woman wrote the article" thing coming from?
Phosphorus? Pfffft, who needs 'em??

User Info: Digitalpixelbit

Digitalpixelbit
6 years ago#6
To be honest, I liked games better when they didn't force some big, huge, wannabe Hollywood blockbuster down your throat.

Plumber + Mysterious Mushroom Kingdom he somehow ended up in + Warp pipes + Princes saving = most epic game of all time.

Two bad ass brothers + Metro City + Hordes of Thugs + Kiddnapped Hooker/Friend = best beat'em up of all time.

Boy all alone + sword + Triforce + Dungeons + Princes saving = most epic adventure of all time.

Plumber + Scaffolding + Crazy Ape tossing barrels at you + Kidnapped Daisy + high score = best arcade game this side of pacman.

User Info: Golden Maven

Golden Maven
6 years ago#7
Agreed with digitalpixel.

If I want some elaborate story, I'll read a book, watch a movie or get into a TV show. Those mediums are about being passive.

Video games are about interaction. They are about gameplay first and foremost, everything else is dressing. Games that focus on telling stories fail and age very, very badly. There's something wrong if my console is on yet my gamepad is idle for longer than, say, 30 seconds (don't take this number too seriously, just get the point).

User Info: rofflchopper

rofflchopper
6 years ago#8
Why do people pay ignorant people like this any attention?

Yea, a video game won't have any mind blowing story, but that doesn't mean it can't tell one.
Dear Society,
Please stop calling Justin Bieber gay. We don't want him either. --- Sincerely, Homosexuals.

User Info: gtaking5

gtaking5
6 years ago#9

From: rofflchopper | #008
Why do people pay ignorant people like this any attention?

Yea, a video game won't have any mind blowing story, but that doesn't mean it can't tell one.


Heavy Rain, Red Dead Redemption, GTA IV, Uncharted Series, are just a few games that I've played with story lines that are leagues ahead of most Movies. Nothing beats The Walking Dead though. I almost cried because of the Mid Season Finale. A lot of people probably did as well. There's nothing more heartbreaking than what happened in that episode.
My name is 'No one' your long lost son, born on the 4th of July
Raised in the barnyards of heroes and cons, left me for dead or alive

User Info: CronoDyne

CronoDyne
6 years ago#10
Video games are about interaction. They are about gameplay first and foremost,

Better inform visual novels and point & click adventures then.
Remember: there's a lot of kids on these boards. Logic doesn't always follow. Think back to when you were 13, raging over things you didn't understand
  1. Boards
  2. PlayStation 3
  3. Tadhg Kelly: "Games can't tell stories"

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived