This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Demons/Dark Souls are ACTION RPGs

  • Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. PlayStation 3
  3. Demons/Dark Souls are ACTION RPGs

User Info: TimeOfTheDark

TimeOfTheDark
4 years ago#1
Why do genres confuse some of you guys so much.

And the word action has th eheavier emphasis on what genre it is, while the rpg elements are minor.

I find new weapons and level up in RDR multiplayer and get new stuff, doesn't make that an RPG.

User Info: zUkUu

zUkUu
4 years ago#2
technically RDR has "RPG elements" - it matters to what degree, then it could be seen as a hybrid.

User Info: este914

este914
4 years ago#3
See when you say 'RPG' I think of a game like Final Fantasy... I dont see D* Souls as a game like that, therefore it is not a RPG to me.
-> este914 <-
WHO ELSE?!

User Info: zUkUu

zUkUu
4 years ago#4
that's your own perception.

User Info: este914

este914
4 years ago#5
Yea I know... so then dont most all games have "RPG" elements added to them?
O_o
-> este914 <-
WHO ELSE?!

User Info: zUkUu

zUkUu
4 years ago#6
este914 posted...
Yea I know... so then dont most all games have "RPG" elements added to them?
O_o


RPG elements doesn't make it a RPG perse - it depends on the focus and size of them. In Dark Souls it's a prominent feature and a huge vital focus of the game, where as in Far Cry 3 for instance, even while rather fleshed out, it's still just an somewhat optional element. you don't have "stats" either. Actually now when I think about it, "stats" could be seen as mandatory requirement.
RPG - Dark Souls, Final Fantasy, Fallout, Diablo
Hybrid - e.g Borderlands 2 (FPS-RPG)
No RPG with RPG Elements - e.g. Farcry 3, GTA:SA, Crysis 2, MANY games have that
No RPG without RPG Elements - The rest ^.^ e.g. Duke Nukem, Uncharted, Street Fighter etc

User Info: ArronAubin

ArronAubin
4 years ago#7
You play the role of a soldier in Call of Duty. CoD is a FPS RPG.

User Info: ScreamingMidget

ScreamingMidget
4 years ago#8
Duh.

User Info: Ochd12

Ochd12
4 years ago#9
TimeOfTheDark posted...
Why do genres confuse some of you guys so much.


More importantly, why would anyone give a **** what someone calls them?

User Info: LAGswitchLARRY

LAGswitchLARRY
4 years ago#10
Topics like these make me sad for the human race
I always win online. DEWD RAIDER: aka UNCHARTED: A Tomb Raider wannabe corridor simulator for casuals who can't play platform or explore on their own.
  1. Boards
  2. PlayStation 3
  3. Demons/Dark Souls are ACTION RPGs

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived